Here's where to go if you want more Lord Of The Rings fic. From here onwards you're on your own. Links in bold are recommended starting places, with the highest amount of quality traffic.

Archives ~ Main
FanFiction.Net ~ Busy archive of (mostly mediocre) slash, het, and gen fic.
Least Expected ~ Large archive for all LOTR fic; mainly slash with some other.
Nindaiwê ~ Growing archive accepting all types of LOTR fic.

Archives ~ Themed
Bit Of Earth ~ Small archive for Sam-centric fiction.
Elf N Hobbit ~ Small archive of Frodo/Legolas slash.
Fellow Ship ~ Aragorn/Boromir slash archive.
Fellowship Of The Legolas ~ Archive for all Legolas-centric fic, any type.
Incredibly True Adventures... ~ Archive for Merry/Boromir/Pippin slash.
The Library Of Moria ~ Medium-size slash archive, all pairings.
Longing ~ Medium-size slash archive for all hobbit pairings.
Sweet Sorcery ~ Archive for slash fic and fan art based on the movies.
Temple Of Gutter: LOTR ~ Medium-size slash archive, all pairings.

Archives ~ Non-Slash
The Barrow Downs ~ Medium-size collection of gen LOTR fiction.
Fingolfin ~ Small collection of gen LOTR fiction.
Middle-Earth Fanfiction Archive ~ Site devoted to Tolkien fan fiction.
Fan.OneRing.net ~ Fan-created stories, poetry, essays, and more.

Real Person Fiction ~ Archives and Mailing Lists
Beyond Middle Earth ~ Archive for stories involving LOTR cast members.
Closer Than Brothers ~ LOTR RPS (Real Person Slash) archive.
LOTR_RPS ~ LOTR Real Person Slash fiction and discussion list.
LOTR_RPS_F ~ LOTR RPS fiction-only list.
Lotrippers ~ URL announcements for RPS-related news, images, and fiction.

Mailing List Directories
Populli Slash Email Lists ~ Comprehensive list of Tolkien-related slash lists.
Tolkien Slash Lists ~ List of Tolkien-related slash lists and archives.

Mailing Lists ~ Fiction-Only
alotrf ~ Small list for all types of LOTR fiction, gen, het, slash, or RPS.
lfx ~ Fiction, art, and zine list for LOTR slash, no discussion.
LOTR_Fanfic ~ Small fiction-only list for anything in the Tolkien Universe.
Middle_Earth_Tales ~ Fiction-only list for all LOTR slash pairings.

Mailing Lists ~ Slash+
Aniron ~ Rated-R-and-under slash fiction and discussion.
AnythingGoes... ~ List for all types of LOTR discussion and fic, gen, het, or slash.
Lord Of The Rings Mailing List ~ Discussion and fiction for anything LOTR.
LOTR_Fanfiction ~ Fiction, art, and discussion list for anything LOTR.
LOTR_Yaoi ~ Slash/yaoi discussion and fiction for LOTR.
tolkien_slash ~ High-traffic discussion and fiction list for all LOTR slash.

Mailing Lists ~ Gen
Home_Of_The_Hobbitses ~ Discussion and fiction for the LOTR series.
The_Istari ~ Sex-free, child-friendly LOTR discussion and fiction.

Mailing Lists ~ Themed
ElfSlutsAnonymous ~ Elf-centric discussion and fiction.
HobbitSlash ~ Hobbit-centric slash discussion and fiction.
slashlords ~ High-traffic discussion and fiction list for all LOTR movie slash.
SweetSorcery ~ Medium-size discussion and fiction list for movie-only slash.
Tolkien_BDSM ~ Kinky slash discussion and fiction for all pairings.

Mailing Lists ~ Slash Pairings
ALSlash ~ Aragorn/Legolas slash fiction and discussion.
Axe_Bow ~ Legolas/Gimli friendship and slash fiction and discussion.
Elf_N_Hobbit ~ Frodo/Legolas slash discussion and fiction.
Elvish_Whims ~ Aragorn/Legolas slash fiction and discussion.
Fellow_Ship ~ Aragorn/Boromir slash discussion and fiction.
Hobbit_Feet ~ Frodo/Sam slash discussion and fiction.
LordsOfSlash ~ Frodo/Legolas and Frodo/Aragorn slash discussion and fiction.
WhetherOrNo ~ Slash discussion and fiction for Sam/Frodo and Merry/Pippin.

Mailing Lists ~ Het Pairings
Aragorn/Arwen ~ Aragorn/Arwen discussion and fiction.

Mailing Lists ~ Characters
BitOfEarth ~ Discussion and fiction about Samwise Gamgee.
Boromir_Slash ~ Boromir and Sean Bean-centric slash and discussion.
ElrondsSlaves ~ Fiction and discussion about Elrond and Hugo Weaving.
Frodo_Slash ~ Frodo-centric slash discussion and fiction.
Gollums_Eyes ~ Fiction and discussion about Gollum/Smeagol.
Legolas Fanship ~ Legolas-centric discussion and fiction.
Legolas_Slash ~ Legolas-centric slash discussion and fiction.
OrlandoBloomFanfic ~ Legolas and Orlando Bloom-centric fiction and discussion.

Mailing Lists ~ Updates/Announcements
FollyOfStarlight ~ Announcement list for the Elrond/Legolas-based slash series.
The Hobbiton Crier ~ Announcement list for the Bit Of Earth website.
lotr_recs ~ Updates list for this site, Lord Of The Rings Recommendations.
LotR_Update ~ Announcement list for the Temple Of Gutter archive.
Rhysenn's Updates ~ Updates regarding Rhysenn's Lord of the Rings slash fic.

Know of a site that should be listed here? Tell me